NEWS ANALYSIS, OCTOBER 19, 2002

 

 

 

A 34-YEAR STORY

 

UU[[[UU

 

The Vietnam War has left so much unforgettable sorrow in many hundred thousand families, Vietnamese and American. The death of a soldier or a civilian killed in battle areas was a great grief to his or her relatives. But they were driven to a still greater grief if he or she was missing without any trace or clue. As the years have been going by, they are still waiting for his or her coming back with their flickering tiny ray of hope.  Or at least, they wish for some concrete news of his or her death that could end their sorrow of waiting.

 

Last week, a report from Vietnam on October 9, 2002 sent to the overseas Vietnamese community media contains a story of such a case.  The time was 6 months prior to the 1968 Tet season (Vietnamese Lunar New Year celebration) when the bloodiest battles took place in January 1968.

 

The media outside Vietnam has known the village of An Truyen near Hue City in the last few years as a hot spot of the movement struggling for religious freedom led by Rev. Nguyen Van Ly, the brave Catholic priest, who is now in prison.

 

During the 1968 Tet Offensive, from three to four thousand victims most of them civilians were slain by the Communist soldiers in the Thua Thien province, Central Vietnam. In An Truyen village, the Rev. Buu Dong, head of the parish was buried alive and his death was confirmed. But a parishioner Ho Thi Xuan, a young girl tailor of 19 years old at the time, just disappeared on July 4, 1967 leaving nothing that could have helped track down her whereabouts, or to be more exact, her remains.

 

The story runs that in August 2002, an An Truyen villager visited a friend in the nearby village. He happened to ask the friend if he knew Miss Ho Thi Xuan.

 

- "Which Xuan?" the friend asked. The An Truyen man said, "Xuan, who was missing before the 1968 Tet Offensive."

 

- "Yes, I do. In 1967, four guerillas brought her here to kill her. When they arrested her at her tailor's shop, they said that she had to go with them for a meeting. After a long walk, she asked the guerrillas, 'Have we reached the meeting place?'  One of them said that he didn't know."

 

The friend continued, "Upon their arrival at my village, the four guerrillas blindfolded her, tied her arms behind her back and pushed her down into a pit and buried her alive."

 

"How come the VC arrested her?"

 

"Because they saw her standing up and walking away from her sewing machine when they passed by. They suspected her of having left home to report their presence to the government soldiers. So they tricked her into following them to a meeting and killed her lest she should pose any danger to them."

 

The An Truyen man asked, "Why do you know it so well?"  His friend said, "One of the four guerrillas has just told me. The three others have passed away. He is still living but he is suffering dementia. Every night this man hears Xuan's voice of 34 years ago echoing at his ears, 'Have we reached the meeting place?'   The man has not been able to sleep. He told me how to get to the killing site and asked me to relay the information to Xuan's family."

 

Her family quickly gathered at the site and dug up the remains, but only parts of which could be collected and brought home on August 31. Xuan's remains stayed at her home in three days for services and visits.

 

After that, she was reburied at the village cemetery where many villagers voiced their protest against the Communist atrocity. Local Communist authorities dared not intercept the mourning services and funeral. But in an action that might be taken as retaliation, the Communist village authorities decided to close down the parish-sponsored elementary classes that helps poor children with regular education.

 

As to the bloody Tet-1968 massacre, the horrible images of the mass graves have deeply imprinted on the memory of those who witnessed the scenes. Among eyes witnesses, a former South Vietnamese lieutenant is still feeling the horror. He told his story, which is somehow accurate and credible, is printed in some overseas Vietnamese magazines including ones on the Internet. We could find his article in Vietnamese posted on the web site http://ngothelinh.web1000.com/HoiKyNguoiLinhGia.html under pseudonym Nguoi Linh Gia (An Old Soldier).

 

At the time, he was a company commander of the Republic of Vietnam 3rd Battalion, 3rd Regiment, First Infantry Division. He was wounded in the battle at Hue Royal Citadel.  According to his knowledge, about 5,600 people were massacred at dozen sites, the two largest of the mass graves were Khe Da Mai (gorge) and Xuan O Dien Dai (sand bar). Some documents reported the total missing at more than 9000.

 

He joined the team of Thua Thien province military command searching for the missing remains in Xuan O Dien Dai, a few kilometers North of Hue. The site was in the area of his responsible for the city security before the Tet-1968 attack.

 

On the sand bar, the victims were transfixed with pointed stakes (bamboo, wood, or metal) running through the trunk from the bottom up to the head. The stakes kept the dead bodies up right in about 40 groups; each group had five to ten victims. Some were beheaded; others were dismembered up to the groin.

 

Beneath the sand floor, the team dug up remains of the victims who had been buried alive. Those victims were found one facing another as if they were talking to each other while their arms were firmly tied behind their back.

 

In several underground shelters filled up with sand, victims' limbs were seen sticking out. Each shelter contained four or five strings of corpses. Their enemy soldiers strung them together with metal wire piercing through their palms. They hammered at the back of some victims' skulls with hard objects while many other victims' faces were smashed up beyond recognition.

 

His narration proved that people who know the events would never forget atrocities such as the 1968 Tet massacres in Hue. It's reasonable to call on them not to harbor thoughts of revenge. But they will never be able to blot the horrible Hue killing out of their memories as the massacre has been recorded in history. It's a hypocritical behavior of one who calls on people to forget such atrocious historical events including the smaller massacre by the American soldiers under Lieutenant Calley at My Lai in the same year.

 

*****

=====================